Mortgage Payment Going Up? Check Your Home Insurance | PolicyPilotUSA
Got a letter saying your mortgage payment is going up? Read this before you pay it.Check now
SponsoredPolicyPilotUSAUpdated November 20263 min read
Homeowners With a Mortgage: Your Home Insurance May Be Why Your Monthly Payment Went Up. Here's How to Check and Fix It
Your monthly mortgage paymentExample
TodayAfter comparing
Loan (principal & interest)$1,412$1,412
Property tax$298$298
Home insurance$241$178
Total per month$1,951$1,888
You pay $63 less every month. Same loan, same rate.
Every dollar you save on home insurance comes straight off your monthly payment. Illustrative example.
When was the last time you saw your home insurance bill?
If you have a mortgage, the honest answer is probably never. Your lender adds a little extra to your payment every month, puts it in an escrow account, and pays your insurance company for you. You don't see the bill. You don't see the price.
So when your policy renews at a higher price, nobody asks you. Your bank just pays it. Then months later, a letter arrives saying your monthly payment is going up, and most homeowners assume it's taxes or the bank.
If you've had the same home insurance for years, you may have been paying more every year without ever being told.
It won't stop on its own. Check now, before your next renewal locks in another year at the higher price.
The good news: home insurance is the one part of your mortgage payment you can change yourself, without touching your loan or your rate. And it's easy: it's all done in one phone call, and the agent takes care of the paperwork with your lender. No forms, no visits to the bank.
FreeNo obligationKeep your current policy if it's better
This check is for homeowners only.
Since you rent, your landlord insures the building. Thanks for checking!
A typical situation
A homeowner in Missouri with a fixed-rate mortgage gets her yearly escrow letter. Her payment is going up again, and she assumes it's property taxes.
In reality, her home insurance went from $168 to $241 a month over three renewals, and she never saw a single bill.
After comparing, she finds the same coverage for $178 a month. At her next escrow review, her mortgage payment drops by $63 a month. Her loan and her rate don't change at all.
Your policy renews automatically every year, often at a new price.
The insurer sends the bill to your lender, not to you.
Your lender pays it from escrow without asking you.
Your lender raises your monthly payment after its yearly escrow review.
Insurers aren't required to tell you a better-priced option exists, and your lender only checks that you're covered, not whether you're paying a fair price. The only way to know if you're overpaying is to check.
Many homeowners think they're stuck with their policy because it's tied to their mortgage. You're not. You choose the insurance company. The bank just pays the bill.
Your mortgage, interest rate, and lender stay exactly the same
Your lender only requires that your home stays properly covered
The agent sends proof of coverage and billing details to your lender
Switching at your renewal date keeps things simple, with no coverage gap
If your current policy is already a good deal, you simply keep it
Don't have home insurance right now? An agent can help you get covered today.
Important: never cancel your current policy before a new one is active. A licensed agent will make sure there's no gap in coverage.
How it works
Answer 3 quick questions. No documents needed.
Have a free 10-minute call with a licensed agent, who checks your rate, your discounts and your coverage.
You decide. Switch if it makes sense, or keep your current policy.
Is the increase always caused by my home insurance?
Not always. Property taxes can also raise your escrow payment. Your escrow statement shows both amounts, and the agent can help you see how much of your payment is insurance.
How much can I save?
It depends on your home, your state and your current policy. Many homeowners qualify for discounts they've never been given (new roof, security system, claims-free, bundling). The agent shows you exact numbers on the call.
Will switching affect my mortgage?
No. Your loan, rate, and lender stay the same. Your lender only needs proof that your home is covered, and the agent takes care of sending it.
What if I'm in the middle of my policy term?
You can usually switch anytime, and your old insurer refunds the unused part of your premium. Many homeowners prefer to switch at renewal to keep it simple.
I don't have home insurance. Can I still call?
Yes. The agent can compare options available in your state and help you get covered.
What if my current policy is already a good deal?
Then you keep it. Comparing is free and there's no obligation.
Who will I be speaking with?
A licensed insurance agent from one of our partners, who can compare home insurance options available in your state.
Find out what you're really paying, before your next renewal